Home
/
Uncover
/
Articles and News
/
Everything you need to know before hiring an ERP and MES for the textile and chemical industries
Artigo

Everything you need to know before hiring an ERP and MES for the textile and chemical industries

The growth of digitalization in manufacturing is a reality, and the use of data technology is becoming an urgent and fundamental measure for the health of industrial operations as a business.

Smart Architecture: how to choose the right system in the Industry 4.0 era

A strategic look at ERP, MES, and SCADA for more efficient and integrated operations.

The growth of digitalization in manufacturing is a reality, and the use of data technology is becoming an urgent and fundamental measure for the health of industrial operations as a business.  

However, the role of each type of digital system within the production architecture is still not clear to many executives and managers. Before we delve into guidance on how to analyze the best solution and procure the most suitable platform for your needs, it is essential to understand the role and limitations of each system.

Terms like ERP, MES, and SCADA are often used inaccurately, which can hinder correct decision-making when procuring technology solutions. This is especially problematic when supervisory system (SCADA) vendors claim to offer execution (MES) functionalities, when in practice they do not meet the essential requirements of that layer.  

Another practical example is the role of manual operations, which are part of the reality of virtually every industrial plant: activities involving human interaction, such as line replenishment, visual inspections, filling out forms, and other actions not automatically captured by automation systems. A complete MES must be able to record and integrate these operations into the production flow, ensuring traceability and data consistency. A SCADA, by definition, was not designed to handle this. Thus, adopting a SCADA with a few interface extensions or data collection features does not mean having an MES. Believing in this equivalence can seriously compromise efficiency, traceability, and the reliability of production information, as well as the company's competitiveness.  

It is important to understand SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) as a more specific technological tool for supervision, which collects signals from sensors and controls machines in real time, monitoring variables such as pressure, temperature, speeds, and alarms, among other data. Although it allows for process visualization and operator interface, it never replaces an MES, as it does not manage production rules, traceability, or order control, nor does it integrate with the ERP system, which focuses on production planning.

At the level closest to automation, we have the PLC (Programmable Logic Controller), the industrial hardware responsible for executing control logic directly on machines and equipment. It operates in millisecond cycles, processing physical inputs and outputs based on predefined rules. While essential for automation, the PLC works in isolation and requires systems like SCADA and MES to provide context to the information it processes.  

Below, we will present practical criteria for procuring ERP and MES solutions with security, clarity, and a focus on real results—avoiding overlaps, gaps, and misdirected investments.

Everything you need to know before procuring ERP and MES for the textile and chemical industries

An ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) and MES (Manufacturing Execution System), in very simple terms, is software designed to integrate and organize all areas and processes of a company—such as finance, purchasing, sales, inventory, planning, and production—into a single platform, facilitating management and improving control, efficiency, and decision-making.

Its use is also indispensable for textile and chemical industries. Given the complexity of production processes and the need for integration between different sectors, this technology is essential to ensure a set of valuable information for more efficient and precise management. In a highly competitive market, having the right system can be the major differentiator, as well as a decisive factor for the health of the business. ERP and MES systems allow for increased operational efficiency, optimized processes, and the integration of all production stages, providing total control and harmony for each one, resulting in higher productivity and easier decision-making.

However, with so many options available, this choice must be made with caution. Inadequate ERP and MES systems can bring more problems than solutions, turning what seemed like an economical investment into a high long-term cost. Therefore, procuring this system must be done with care and planning. In this article, we will answer the main questions you should consider when choosing an ERP and MES platform for the textile or chemical industry, looking at practical examples, concrete data, and strategies to maximize benefits.

What is ERP?

ERP stands for Enterprise Resource Planning. It is an information system that integrates a company's data and processes, allowing for the management of all operational stages in a single environment.

Thus, its focus is on strategy and planning, operating with broader horizons and less frequent update cycles. It manages sales orders, purchasing, inventory, costs, finance, and, in an industrial context, plans production orders, for example. In addition to integrating processes, an ERP acts to reduce so-called transaction costs—an organizational economics term referring to inefficiencies like rework, communication failures, and data duplication. By centralizing information, ERP also reduces agency costs, minimizing information asymmetries between managers and teams, and promoting more transparency in management and operational control. In other words, with an ERP, it is possible to unify information, centralize workflows, automate processes, and align internal communication. This ensures that all areas of the company, such as production, inventory, sales, and finance, operate in an integrated and efficient manner. Furthermore, the system transforms data into structured information, which facilitates strategic decision-making, increases operational efficiency, and helps reduce errors and rework.

What is MES?

MES (Manufacturing Execution System) is the system that provides operational visibility and control to the factory floor; without it, the gap between planning and execution can be decisive for your results. It is software that monitors, controls, and manages factory production in real time, acting directly on production and manufacturing execution. It collects data directly from machines and processes, organizes and tracks every production stage, work orders, validates parameters, and manages quality, traceability, and efficiency. Crucially, it also incorporates manual operations such as assembly, inspections, production reporting, or downtime. It provides vital information on production progress, quality, traceability, and efficiency to connect planning (ERP) with the factory floor. In this way, it acts as a bridge between production operations and ERP planning systems, with the primary goal of making operations as efficient as possible, reducing costs, improving production quality, and enabling the factory to realign processes with agility and precision.

How will ERP and MES help your business?

Implementing an integrated ERP and MES system offers numerous benefits, especially for the textile and chemical industries, where process complexity demands a high level of control and precision. It optimizes operations, minimizes manual errors, improves communication between departments, and enables more efficient strategic management. This provides greater predictability and agility in decision-making, ensuring a more integrated and competitive operation.

A system that integrates ERP and MES in the textile and chemical sectors is essential for improving production control, raw material traceability, regulatory compliance, product quality, and, above all, the overall health of the business. For example, it contributes in several ways:

• Production automation: reduces reliance on manual tasks, promoting greater operational efficiency and increased productivity.

• Raw material traceability: enables detailed tracking of raw materials and products at every stage of the process, helping to reduce waste and control inventory.

• Regulatory compliance: facilitates adherence to legal and regulatory requirements through features such as automated report generation and the storage of mandatory documents.

• Quality control: allows for the standardization of processes and the identification of critical points and failures, offering continuous improvement and the delivery of products that meet market standards.

How to conduct effective research on ERP/MES systems?

Before beginning your search, it is essential to thoroughly understand your company’s requirements and define which features are critical to ensuring efficient operations. Once these points have been established, the next step is to determine a budget, taking into account licensing, implementation, maintenance, and infrastructure costs.

Should I hire an ERP/MES system specific to the textile and chemical sector or opt for a more generic system?

Choosing between a specialized platform and a more generic system depends on several factors, such as your industry's specific needs and your available budget. Generic systems may meet basic demands, but they often fail to provide managers with the specific insights crucial for operations. A system specialized for these sectors, however, offers tailored features that deliver significantly greater benefits and returns.

Specialized ERP/MES systems feature modules developed to meet the specific needs of every stage of your production process with maximum efficiency, from raw materials to the finished product. Key advantages of an ERP/MES system specifically designed for the textile and chemical industries include:

• Raw material and supply management: facilitates detailed control of materials used, optimizing usage and reducing waste.

• Batch and product traceability: enables rigorous tracking of product origin and destination, ensuring greater control over production.

• Quality control: ensures products meet established standards, minimizing defects and improving quality.

• Regulatory compliance: includes features that ensure production meets specific safety, environmental, and quality requirements defined by law.

Furthermore, because specialized ERP/MES systems already include many out-of-the-box features, the implementation process is faster and more effective. Generic systems require customizations and adaptations to meet specific sector needs, which can pose risks to results and may still fail to support all industry demands. A specialized system covers all the peculiarities of each segment of the operation and, by reducing implementation time, improves the return on investment curve.

To determine the ideal system, conduct a detailed analysis of your industry's requirements, taking into account factors such as internal processes, company size, growth plans, available budget, and the time required for implementation. To structure this process well, it is important to avoid "technological myopia," where decisions are made based solely on trends or exaggerated promises without considering how well the solution actually fits the company's strategy and culture. There is no magic; an ERP/MES platform should be viewed as a powerful tool—a means to transform processes and generate value, not an end in itself.

How do you conduct effective research on ERP/MES systems?

Before starting your search, you must deeply understand your company's requirements and define which features are essential for operational performance. Once these points are established, it is time to set a budget, taking into account licensing, implementation, maintenance, and infrastructure costs.

What are RFI and RFP processes, and why should I consider them before choosing a system?

We strongly recommend that before making a final decision on which ERP/MES to hire, the company conducts formal RFI (Request for Information) and RFP (Request for Proposal) processes. The RFI is an initial stage where the company collects general information from different system vendors to better understand the options available on the market, their features, track record, client success stories, and their identity and alignment with your specific industry. This stage helps filter options and gain clarity on what is relevant to your operation. The RFP, in turn, is more detailed and structured. Here, the company already knows what it needs and sends a formal request for proposals to the selected vendors. The document includes technical and functional requirements, deadlines, commercial terms, evaluation criteria, and project objectives. Responding to an RFP allows you to compare solutions in greater depth and base your choice on concrete, comparable data. Including these steps in the ERP and MES selection process contributes to a more secure, rational decision that is aligned with your company's real needs.

Benefits of these processes

• Ensure transparency and fairness in the selection process.

• Allow for a structured comparison between system vendors.

• Increase the likelihood of the solution fitting your business.

• Reduce the risks of a hasty or inadequate choice.

• They facilitate internal alignment between the areas involved in the project.

Including these steps in the ERP and MES selection process contributes to a more secure, rational decision that is aligned with your company's actual needs.

With this information in hand, begin your search for ERP/MES system providers. Research online, ask for recommendations from other business owners in the sector, and evaluate the features of each system, checking for customization, integration, and usability, compatibility with your segment, and whether they meet your company's needs. Additionally, research the provider's reputation, track record, knowledge of your industry, and success stories, and request practical demonstrations to test the system. Talking to current clients can provide important insights into the real-world user experience. Don't forget to also evaluate the technical support offered, implementation time, the scalability of the ERP/MES system, and whether the platform stays updated with new technologies.

After this detailed research, request proposals from the providers that meet your needs and compare the options. This way, you will be able to make an informed decision. However, remember that this is a step that can change the growth trajectory of your company, and that price should not be considered in isolation. The choice should be made with a long-term focus, as a wrong decision can generate high costs and take a lot of time to correct.

What attributes are essential in an ERP/MES for the textile and chemical industries?

An effective ERP/MES system for the textile and chemical industries must be highly specialized, offering specific features and parameters to optimize operations. To meet the production demands of this sector, the system must include:

• Production Planning and Control (PPC) and traceability: detailed management of production processes, including capacity planning, batch production control, and tracking of raw materials and finished products.

• Inventory and raw material management: real-time monitoring of raw materials, supplies, and finished products, ensuring proper storage conditions, especially for sensitive materials like chemicals and fabrics.

• Quality control and compliance: features for performing quality tests, issuing certificates of compliance, and meeting safety and environmental standards.

• Purchasing and supplier management: efficient supplier control, order tracking, deadline compliance, and quality assurance of purchased materials.

• Financial and cost management: precise calculation of production costs, profit margin control, and financial forecasting to promote better decision-making.

• Sales and logistics management: order monitoring, batch traceability, and distribution tracking to ensure timely deliveries and efficient logistics control.

• Reports and predictive analytics: generation of custom reports and real-time analytics to identify opportunities for improvement and reduce waste.

• Integration with other systems: ability to integrate with production and manufacturing resource management systems (ERP and MES), industrial automation (SCADA), tax and accounting systems, among others, centralizing data and improving operational efficiency.

Technological Innovations

When hiring an ERP, evaluate innovation as a key factor to ensure the solution evolves with your company, avoiding future obsolescence. Focus on neutral and objective criteria to compare providers, prioritizing a clear roadmap and technologies aligned with the industrial sector.

Evaluation Criteria

Check for frequent updates and the use of fundamental technologies such as cloud computing, process flow automation, AI agents, and native customization tools. A clear evolution roadmap will prevent extra future costs associated with stagnant systems.

Question the level of incremental innovation (continuous improvements) versus radical innovation (disruptive transformations), aligning it with your company's appetite for change. Metrics such as novelty (technical and perceived), usability, variety of solutions, and profitability help quantify innovative potential.

Emerging Technologies

Prioritize ERPs with native AI for predictive analytics, process automation, and real-time insights—the dominant trends. Seek IoT support for industrial monitoring, full mobility, and big data integration, ensuring scalability for industries like textile and chemical. Composable (modular) solutions allow for agile customization without vendor lock-in, boosting competitiveness.

Criteria
What should be evaluated?
Sample questions
Roadmap
Update frequency and product roadmap
“What innovations have been launched in the past two years? What is the roadmap for the coming years?”
AI / Automation
Native integration and proven ROI
“How does AI optimize processes? Are there proven cases of cost reduction?”
Metrics
Innovation, usability, and profitability
“How do you measure innovation in your product releases?”
Scalability
Cloud, IoT, and modularity
“Can it support growth without requiring a system rewrite?”

These steps guide an unbiased evaluation, positioning innovation as a strategic investment.

These steps guide an impartial evaluation, positioning innovation as a strategic investment.

Are ERP and MES only for large-scale industries?

ERP and MES systems can provide significant benefits to companies of all sizes. Today, there are many scalable system options that cater to everything from small factories to large industrial groups. Many ERP/MES solutions are modular and customizable, allowing companies to start with basic features and add new capabilities as they grow and their needs evolve.

Regardless of your industry's size, a specialized system will help automate processes, reduce errors, improve quality, and provide greater control over production, increasing market competitiveness and supporting your business growth plans.

Can ERPs and MES be integrated with other systems we already use?

Yes, they can and should be integrated with other systems. Today, most modern ERPs and MES allow for integration with industrial automation systems like SCADA, warehouse management systems (WMS), and even financial platforms.

Integrating the systems used within a company is essential, especially for the textile and chemical industries, which have multiple production stages. This integration connects all departments and centralizes information, improving management and data control across the entire company. This is fundamental for optimizing processes and ensuring effective management.

What are the stages and how long does it take to implement an ERP and MES in a textile or chemical industry?

The implementation time for such a system can vary depending on factors such as the complexity of the company's processes, its size, and the level of system customization, among others. Generally, the process can take anywhere from a few months to over a year and is divided into several stages. See below.

ERP/MES Implementation Stages

• Phase 1 – Planning and requirements analysis: After hiring the provider, planning begins, taking into account the company's specific needs and requirements. In this phase, a schedule is defined, goals are established, and alignment is achieved with all departments regarding the project's phases and objectives.

• Phase 2 – Process analysis: In this stage, internal company processes are mapped to understand how the ERP and MES can integrate and optimize them, always considering the industry's specific characteristics.

• Phase 3 – System configuration and customization: The system is configured and personalized to meet the company's needs, with adjustments to modules and integration with existing systems.

• Phase 4 – System testing: Tests are conducted in a controlled environment to ensure that all functionalities and integrations are operating correctly.

• Phase 5 – Training: All involved employees receive training to use the ERP/MES and become familiar with the new system. Each area receives specific training focused on the features most relevant to their operation. This prepares the team for a smooth and highly efficient transition.

• Phase 6 – Go-live and monitoring: The system goes live, and the provider closely monitors the ERP/MES performance, offering support and addressing any minor issues.

• Phase 7 – Post-implementation adjustments: Based on team feedback, adjustments are made to the system to improve processes and ensure greater operational efficiency.

• Phase 8 – Maintenance and continuous improvement: The provider performs regular system maintenance, implementing enhancements and adapting the system to the company's new needs and market innovations.

Time estimates

[{"_id":"20a21adb-fad7-1f6a-a77a-a4cdd163e7f6","tag":"p","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Paragraph","classes":[],"children":["19b8f1d6-ee88-ce3a-f157-025e58fa2e55","fb6c999f-0436-894d-eea1-b37d32a44969"]},{"_id":"19b8f1d6-ee88-ce3a-f157-025e58fa2e55","tag":"strong","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Strong","classes":[],"children":["31b32a79-0cd0-47a6-313d-1fe86cdec7cd"]},{"v":"Pequenas indústrias:","_id":"31b32a79-0cd0-47a6-313d-1fe86cdec7cd","text":true},{"v":" 4-6 meses para ERPs e MES baseados em nuvem.","_id":"fb6c999f-0436-894d-eea1-b37d32a44969","text":true},{"_id":"c34863e0-1797-a348-c756-18ef2ee9ff64","tag":"p","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Paragraph","classes":[],"children":["c9090653-3e24-032e-6b42-d313dadb8610","aaa44054-c134-3f0b-9aa5-e79683a25366"]},{"_id":"c9090653-3e24-032e-6b42-d313dadb8610","tag":"strong","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Strong","classes":[],"children":["a6483847-20e8-d1d0-e98c-233e15a5f105"]},{"v":"Médias indústrias:","_id":"a6483847-20e8-d1d0-e98c-233e15a5f105","text":true},{"v":" 6-12 meses, dependendo do nível de personalização.","_id":"aaa44054-c134-3f0b-9aa5-e79683a25366","text":true},{"_id":"fed406d4-ee13-e7ab-ede7-cc62874c84a5","tag":"p","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Paragraph","classes":[],"children":["4a2a06fb-a651-bd9e-2500-9610bd550bde","5e861082-8270-24f2-0519-c3f0696a9f26"]},{"_id":"4a2a06fb-a651-bd9e-2500-9610bd550bde","tag":"strong","data":{"attr":{"id":""},"xattr":[],"search":{"exclude":false},"devlink":{"slot":"","runtimeProps":{}},"visibility":{"conditions":[],"keepInHtml":{"tag":"False","val":{}}},"displayName":""},"type":"Strong","classes":[],"children":["a80cf714-f0d8-1ffb-7662-816edef759b3"]},{"v":"Grandes indústrias:","_id":"a80cf714-f0d8-1ffb-7662-816edef759b3","text":true},{"v":" 12-18 meses, em função da complexidade de processos e integrações.","_id":"5e861082-8270-24f2-0519-c3f0696a9f26","text":true}]

What are the biggest challenges when implementing an ERP/MES?

The implementation process can be challenging, especially in the textile and chemical industries, due to the need for customization to meet the specific demands of these segments, which can increase project time and costs. Furthermore, these industries operate under strict safety and quality standards, requiring the ERP/MES system to be compliant with specific regulations. Ensuring that the system is implemented with precision, agility, and full compliance with these standards is crucial, making the choice of a system provider specialized in the textile or chemical industry the most advantageous solution.

In addition to reviewing and standardizing internal processes before implementation, it is also essential to manage costs and timelines well to avoid failures, delays, and unexpected expenses. System integration can be another obstacle, especially when using legacy systems that are not compatible with the new platform. While this does not prevent implementation, it makes the process more complex, so it is necessary to verify integration requirements before contracting a new ERP/MES.

In this regard, data migration—such as information on customers, suppliers, inventory, and production—is a critical factor. It is important to ensure that the transition process and the migrated data are accurate and of high quality to avoid inconsistencies or data loss.

Another relevant point during the migration to a new system is the risk of losing human capital and tacit knowledge. Without an adequate process for knowledge transfer and recording information from the previous system, the company may lose valuable insights that supported its operations.
Another challenge is team resistance to the new system, as many are accustomed to the old one. To minimize this, it is essential to provide comprehensive training and ensure ongoing support, providing the team with security and confidence.

Ensuring that the system is implemented with precision, agility, and full compliance with these standards is crucial, making the choice of a system provider specialized in the textile or chemical industry the most advantageous solution.

Industry-specific risks

The textile and chemical sectors face operational challenges and specific risks that directly impact costs, production efficiency, quality, and regulatory compliance. Adopting a specialized ERP/MES system is essential to mitigate these risks through greater control, integration, and process precision.

• Textile Sector:
A lack of synchronization between planning, scheduling, and production execution can result in high intermediate inventory, increased immobilized capital, and operational inefficiencies. In a practical case at the company Costa Rica, which has a daily production of 70 tons of finished knit fabric, an intermediate inventory (buffer) equivalent to 6 days of raw knit production—about 420 tons—was maintained. With the implementation of Operacional SGT and improvements in production planning and sequencing, this volume was reduced to 4 days (280 tons), generating a direct 33% reduction in immobilized capital. This result demonstrates how production control and synchronization reduce financial risks and increase operational efficiency.

• Chemical Sector:
The lack of integration between departments, the absence of standardized processes, and poor traceability represent significant risks, such as production errors, regulatory non-compliance, and quality control failures. The adoption of the Process system by Color Química mitigated these risks by promoting operational integration, standardizing processes and costs, optimizing production planning, and significantly increasing information security. Furthermore, the traceability of batches, raw materials, and finished products became more agile and precise, strengthening quality control and ensuring greater adherence to regulatory requirements.

• Recipe Formulation Assurance:
The absence of strict control in recipe formulation can result in unwanted chemical reactions, explosion risks, product contamination, and production losses. Specialized systems ensure the standardization, validation, and control of formulations, significantly reducing operational, safety, and quality risks.

• Product and Process Engineering:
A lack of structured control in product and process engineering can lead to specification errors, rework, increased costs, and development inefficiencies. The use of integrated systems ensures greater precision in the development and improvement of products and production processes, optimizing the product lifecycle—from conception to delivery—and ensuring greater efficiency, quality, and competitiveness.

Change Management

To overcome the team's adaptation phase, adopt change management strategies:

• Proactive communication: hold meetings to explain benefits, such as task simplification and reduced rework, highlighting "what's in it for me" for each employee.

• Change leaders: designate supervisors as "champions" to promote system integration and act as a liaison with management.

• Personalized training: offer role-specific training (e.g., operators learn traceability, finance focuses on reports), reducing the learning curve by up to 50%.

• Incentives: implement bonuses or other recognition methods for teams that adopt the system quickly.

• Continuous feedback: create channels (e.g., weekly surveys) to collect employee impressions and adjust training.

Despite the challenges, a successful implementation is entirely possible and much more efficient and accessible when carried out by vendors specializing in your production sector. This requires detailed planning, appropriate training, clear communication between teams, and ongoing support throughout the process.

A practical example of change management is the cultural adoption project for the SGT Operational ERP/MES at Vicunha, one of the largest textile manufacturers in Brazil. To engage employees, Vicunha developed specific communication branding, creating a visual identity that reinforces its importance and facilitates adoption and acceptance by the team.
Launch events were organized, such as workshops and interactive presentations, with the goal of familiarizing employees with the ERP and its benefits. The company also defined "champions" in each department—leaders who act as project ambassadors, promoting buy-in and helping to clarify questions. In addition, a structured adoption plan was implemented, with clear goals and defined timelines, ensuring a smooth transition and aligning organizational culture with the system's new features.

What is the impact of implementing an ERP/MES on factory routine?

In the textile and chemical industries, an ERP/MES system automates processes, allowing for the tracking of all production stages and ensuring that processes meet quality standards and environmental regulations. Furthermore, the system facilitates quality control, real-time monitoring, and integrates the factory with other departments, such as purchasing, sales, and finance, ensuring that everyone works with the same information. This eliminates data loss and improves operational efficiency.

Adopting an ERP and MES platform significantly transforms factory routine. Processes become more organized, communication more efficient, and there is a reduction in waste and rework. During the transition and familiarization period for employees with the new system, temporary interruptions in daily processes may occur. However, with proper training and practice, the team adapts quickly and the benefits begin to be observed.

What is the average cost of an ERP/MES for the textile and chemical sector?

Just like the implementation time, the cost of an ERP/MES platform for the textile and chemical industries can vary considerably, depending on factors such as company size, process complexity, licensing model, and the chosen vendor. The cost can also be influenced by the number of users and the subscription model (single license, monthly fee, or SaaS).
Cloud-based solutions tend to be more accessible and scalable, while on-premise systems may require a larger investment in infrastructure and maintenance.

In addition to the cost of the system itself, it is important to consider additional expenses, such as customization, team training, technical support, and updates. Companies with more specific processes, such as batch traceability and chemical formula control, may need a higher level of customization, which can impact the final investment.

To make the best choice, it is essential to evaluate more than just the price. Compare the features of each system, especially how it solves business challenges, and analyze the return each solution offers, particularly regarding efficiency and management optimization. This way, you can ensure the investment brings real benefits.

How to compare different ERP/MES systems in terms of cost-benefit?

Choosing an ERP/MES system for the textile and chemical industries goes far beyond price. Opting for a solution based solely on cost can lead to future problems, such as implementation difficulties, lack of adequate support, and the need to switch systems, which generates more expenses and frustration. When evaluating a system, you need a strategic vision, taking into account not only the initial investment but also its efficiency, scalability, and long-term impact on operations.

Key evaluation criteria:

Initial cost vs. total cost: some low-priced ERP and MES solutions may have hidden costs related to implementation, support, and customization. Consider:

Licensing model: on-premise systems require the purchase of licenses and dedicated infrastructure, while cloud-based systems operate via monthly or annual subscriptions.

Customization: the ERP/MES must adapt to the specific needs of the textile or chemical sector, which may require additional tailoring.

Staff training: a system that is inexpensive but difficult to use can lead to extra costs for ongoing training.

Support and maintenance: an ERP/MES without efficient support can create more problems than it solves. Before deciding, evaluate:

Response time and support channels (email, phone, chat);

Availability of specialized support for the textile and chemical sectors;

Regular updates to keep the system secure and aligned with your company's needs.

Features and modularity: choosing a system based solely on price can lead to a generic solution with limited functions that fail to meet your industry's requirements. Evaluate:

Whether the system has all the essential features to meet your company's demands;

The potential for scalability, allowing for the addition of modules as the company grows, avoiding the need to migrate to another system in the future.
Integration with other systems: an ERP/MES that does not communicate well with existing systems can lead to data loss and rework. Check:

The ability to integrate with other systems (SCADA, WMS, other ERPs), accounting tools, CRM, among others;

The availability of APIs that allow connections with other platforms.

Investment benefits: implementing an ERP/MES is an investment to improve operational efficiency in the industry, facilitating management and strategic decision-making. Evaluate whether the system ensures:

Production optimization and error reduction;

Improved inventory management, preventing waste and shortages of raw materials;

Regulatory compliance, reducing the risk of fines and rework.

Satisfaction and usability: a system that is difficult to use can lead to employee resistance and compromise expected results. Evaluate:

Whether the solution is intuitive and easy to use;

Whether training is included to upskill the team;

Success stories and feedback from companies in the same sector to avoid surprises

The success of an ERP and MES system is also tied to its consistency with the company's strategy. When technology is aligned with organizational culture, business objectives, and actual operational processes, efficiency and productivity gains become more sustainable over time.

How do you measure the success of an ERP/MES implementation?

After implementing a system in the textile and chemical industries, it is essential to evaluate its efficiency to ensure that operational improvement and cost-reduction goals have been met. Measuring success effectively involves tracking a series of key performance indicators (KPIs), which help not only to gauge financial results but also the operational effectiveness of the ERP/MES over time.

Key metrics for evaluating implementation success

• System adoption and usage: Evaluate the acceptance of the ERP/MES within the company by observing how many employees are using the system effectively, and conduct periodic surveys to understand user experience and identify areas for improvement in the interface or usage processes.

• Operational efficiency: The system should directly impact the optimization of operations, resulting in time and productivity gains. Analyze the reduction in manual processes, production time, and improvements in the control of critical processes.

• Quality and compliance: Assess whether there has been a reduction in production errors, improvements in final product quality, and how well the ERP/MES has met industry standards and regulations without incurring additional costs due to non-compliance.

• Cost reduction: Track the savings generated by reducing material waste and lowering inventory levels of raw materials and supplies.

• Return on Investment (ROI): Calculate the return by comparing the total cost of implementation with the gains in efficiency, cost reduction, and increased productivity. Increases in production volume, market expansion, and revenue growth also indicate that the ERP/MES system has contributed to the company's success.

• Flexibility and scalability: Evaluate whether the system has been able to support process changes and company expansion without compromising performance or requiring major adjustments.

• Post-implementation support: Analyze the quality of support after implementation, considering the vendor's agility in resolving issues as they arise. It is also important to analyze whether there have been regular system updates to ensure it continues to meet the company's needs as it evolves.

Expected results

Studies indicate that specialized ERP/MES systems can provide measurable benefits (Gartner, ERP ROI Reports):

• ROI: 150%-300% within 2-3 years, depending on the size and efficiency of the implementation.

• Waste reduction: 15%-25% in inventory, due to real-time control.

• Error reduction: 20%-30% in manual processes, such as production planning.

With these KPIs, it is possible to conduct a detailed and objective assessment of the impact of the ERP/MES implementation in the textile and chemical industries, helping to identify areas for improvement and ensuring that the system's benefits are fully realized.

Conclusion

Choosing and implementing an ERP/MES platform for the textile and chemical industries requires careful planning, in-depth research, and a precise analysis of your company's needs. Opting for a system that meets the specific demands of the sector while offering integration and ongoing support can transform your management, increase market competitiveness, and change the trajectory of your business.

Operacional offers scalable, specialized solutions for the textile and chemical industries. Our modules are customizable, covering everything from basic requirements to the most complex needs, all while remaining aligned with your company's goals. Furthermore, our systems integrate seamlessly with other management platforms—whether financial, tax, accounting, or automation-based—as well as machine and process supervision and control systems (SCADA), with continuous support from our technical team to identify adjustments and implement updates whenever necessary.

We believe that the best results come from constant process improvement. If you value the continuous evolution of your industry and are looking for a complete, specialized ERP/MES solution to optimize every stage of your production, Operacional has the ideal system for you. Operacional SGT is our ERP and MES system specialized for textile manufacturers, while Operacional Process is the ERP and MES system developed for the chemical industry. Speak with our experts at operacional.com for practical demonstrations and to learn more about our solutions and features.

Next steps

Choosing an ERP/MES is a decision that changes the trajectory of an industry. Before comparing vendors and prices, the first step is to clearly understand how your operation works today: what is already systematized, what is still manual, and where the bottlenecks are.

That is exactly what Operacional's diagnosis delivers. With IDUS, the Systemic Utilization Index, our specialized consulting team measures your plant's level of digitalization, benchmarks the current situation against market best practices, and defines a tailored transformation plan, with clear priorities and execution order. The system decision comes afterwards, grounded in real data.

With more than three decades of experience in the textile and chemical industries, Operacional develops Operacional SGT, the ERP and MES specialized for the textile industry, and Operacional Process, developed for the chemical and process industries, as shown by the results achieved at Costa Rica and Color Química.

To learn more, visit operacional.com or call +55 47 3231-3100.

Talk to our experts and find out where to start.

Talk to our experts